Telling truth

Opinion / Raymond Zhou

 Telling truth
By Raymond Zhou (China Daily)
Updated: 2005-10-22 06:23

With the passing of Ba Jin, it's time to look into the legacy of this
towering figure in Literary China.

If you scan the online landscape, you may come to the conclusion that Ba
Jin was well-respected, but didn't strike a chord with China's netizens.
Most postings are made up of one-sentence condolences, proper and formal.

That is not unusual. The online demographic is heavily skewed towards the
young, who may not have read his masterpieces such as "Family" and
"Chilly Night." Or even if they have, it may be hard for those born in
the 1980s to identify with children of the May Fourth Movement.

For those of us who went through the 1980s as adults, Ba Jin represented
the epitome of a writer or artist, which is integrity. He was not afraid
to cut through his own wounds of the "cultural revolution" (1966-76) and
expose his own "sins" while most people of his age and stature would be
happily swallowing in their survival skills and accolades.

The memoirs he published in the post-cultural revolution years have a
relevancy that overshadows his previous novels, and they can be
crystallized into this three-word motto: shuo zhen hua, or speak the
truth.

It may sound as hackneyed as every father's admonition. But it may be the
most stinging legacy from this prolific writer whose life spanned a whole
century.

Speaking the truth may not be easy and often brings on disastrous
consequences. I'm not just talking about here and now. The whole notion
of civilization can be construed as couching truth in palatable
languages, or more bluntly, not telling it as it is.

If the "mirror on the wall" had told the queen that Snow White is not
more beautiful than her, there might not be a poisonous apple incident.

Since this is a fairy tale and the queen is evil personified, nobody
would blame the mirror for having a big mouth. However, in real life,
there can be at least two types of approaches to giving vent to truth.

One is the artist type. An artist should by nature be truthful to himself
and his ideals. That does not mean he cannot use symbols or other
circuitous means, but that should be his own choice. He can choose to
whisper, sing or even rant and does not need to think much of how others
will respond.

On the other side is the politician, who, on most occasions, cannot blurt
out what is on his mind. He will have to identify his goal first, and
then find the best persuasive expression to reach it.

In novels and films, the protagonist is generally a straight arrow and
calls a spade a spade. A hero who tricks the villain, without
provocation, into foolery and defeat may automatically lose his moral
credentials.

When a child is growing up, he or she is torn between these two forces:
You must tell the truth and not lie; you should speak properly and not
hurt others' feelings. This paradox plagues us into our adult lives.

Truth can hurt, and the object is not only evil queens. The Western
culture is so enamoured with the cute appearance of babies that you'd be
forced to lie if a baby has the face of Quasimodo. Seinfeld, the 1990s
hit television sitcom, made a whole episode out of breaking this taboo
when the main characters dropped their jaws and got convulsed in horror
at the sight of a friend's newborn.

And as pop songs go, the truth shall set you free. But in reality, the
truth can also haunt you for the rest of your life. That's why we have
the saying "blissfully ignorant."

I'm not sabotaging Ba Jin's axiom here. As everyone is aware, not telling
the truth can be disastrous, which was illustrated in the 2003 SARS
epidemic. But telling the truth is not as simple as black and white. The
whole public relations business exists to present "truth" in a
seller-friendly way.

Withholding truth does not necessarily mean telling lies because the
latter is often viewed as an act of desperation or a sign of imminent
failure. But not telling the whole truth is almost de rigueur in modern
life. It is the line between social etiquette and massive deception that
we should watch out for.

Ba Jin had a lofty ideal. Truth be told, no sane person can achieve it
100 per cent. But a society that totally ignores it will be insane.

Email: raymondzhou@chinadaily.com.cn

(China Daily 10/22/2005 page4)

Hot Talks

 President's List of Do's and Don'ts for China

 How important is 'Face' (Mian Zi) to everyone?

 The Woeful Health of the Nation

 China, USA should be natural allies

 Beijing's leverage over Taiwan

Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours

20071124 http://www.hellomandarin.net