Learn Chinese online - Drawing the line between art and porn

?  ?

Opinion / Zou Hanru

Drawing the line between art and porn

By Zou Hanru (China Daily)
Updated: 2007-07-27 06:44

How to define art and pornography is at the center of a debate heating up
after the Hong Kong Television and Entertainment Licensing Authority
(TELA), the government's decency watchdog, asked a publisher at a book
fair last week to withdraw a work containing paintings of nudes.

It is not clear whether or not the TELA knew the paintings, mainly
depictions of Western myths, were among the collections of celebrated
museums around the world, such as the Louvre in France, but it took back
its "advice" after the episode came under the public glare the following
day.

This is not the first time there has been controversy in Hong Kong caused
by confusion over the delicate line between art and obscenity.

In 1995, the TELA referred a picture of the completely naked statue of
David, which was on public display, to the Obscene Articles Tribunal
(OAT). The tribunal, which comprises a presiding magistrate and two
adjudicators, ruled the statue of David was "obscene". The case went all
the way to the High Court where the "obscene" ruling was ultimately
overturned.

It must be pointed out that the TELA and the OAT usually act on
complaints made by members of the public. Moreover, they pledge to follow
closely standards for taste and decency accepted by the community and
reflect them in their decision.

Not everyone in the community feels the same, however. What is artistic
to some might be perceived as offensive to others.

So, what is art? And how is it different from pornography?

Dictionaries come in handy when we try to draw this line.

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a work of art is something
that gives aesthetic satisfaction and sensational feelings to the viewer
or listener. The New Oxford Dictionary of English defines art as, "the
expression or application of human creative skill and imagination ...
producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional
power".

The online encyclopedia Wikipedia says a work of art stimulates not only
the human senses but also the human mind and spirit.

As for "pornography", the Oxford Dictionary describes it as being
"intended to stimulate erotic rather than aesthetic or emotional
feelings". That is to say, "art" conveys "beauty" and "pornography"
generates erotic stimulation. But the definition of "beauty" can be as
evasive as "art".

It can mean different things to different people. A picture might look
"beautiful" to the trained eye but incomprehensible to the novice,
especially when it comes to abstract art. Not everybody is able to admire
Picasso's paintings, for example.

That a modern and cosmopolitan city like Hong Kong could have such a
divergence of opinions over what is "art" and what is "pornography" is
probably because the city is a place where Eastern and Western cultures
meet. Liberal and conservative ideas about sex coexist in the same
society.

It is a healthy phenomenon to have such differing ideas over various
concepts. The more people argue about anything, the more they will come
to understand the matter of contention, as long as the debate is
conducted in a rational manner. That is not to say there is no principle
to go by. There is the law - the obscene and indecent articles ordinance,
for instance - to resort to. And there is the mainstream opinion.

What these institutions should do is not only look up the relevant legal
provisions, but also hold public forums to gauge the prevailing aesthetic
and moral standards in the community.

There is, however, one simpler and more convenient way to handle this
issue - if something has already been classified as a piece of art by
centuries of art critics, it is most probably not a work of pornography.

E-mail: zouhr@chinadaily.com.hk

(China Daily 07/27/2007 page10)

Hot Talks

* Should Beida recruit more recommended students?
* Nude women and Peking Opera: pornography or art?
* War in Iraq lost?
* Costa Rica cut ties with Taiwan: Who's next?
* Will China follow USA "way of life"?

Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours

Learn Chinese, Chinese School, Learning Materials, Mandarin audio lessons, Chinese writing lessons, Chinese vocabulary lists, About chinese characters, News in Chinese, Go to China, Travel to China, Study in China, Teach in China, Dictionaries, Learn Chinese Painting, Your name in Chinese, Chinese calligraphy, Chinese songs, Chinese proverbs, Chinese poetry, Chinese tattoo, Beijing 2008 Olympics, Mandarin Phrasebook, Chinese editor, Pinyin editor, China Travel, Travel to Beijing, Travel to Tibet